The Rent and Yield
Strategies

New Zealand Property Resale Losses Hit 14-Year High

Nearly 16% of New Zealand homes resold in the September quarter fetched less than their purchase price, the highest loss rate since 2012.

Nearly 16% of New Zealand homes resold in the September quarter fetched less than their purchase price, the highest loss...

New Zealand property resale losses have reached a 14-year high. Almost 16 per cent of properties resold in the three months through September sold for less than their purchase price, according to the latest Pain and Gain report from property data firm CoreLogic. This 15.8% loss-making resale rate is the highest share recorded since the third quarter of 2012.

The deterioration in resale conditions has been more gradual than after the global financial crisis, but the trend is clear. Profitability has fallen to 84.2%, a significant drop from its peak of about 99 per cent in 2022. The housing market has shifted from offering easy wins to delivering selective outcomes.

Market Slump Drives Prolonged Losses

New Zealand’s housing market is in a prolonged slump, with prices falling for a seventh straight month to the lowest level since late 2020. This broad decline is putting pressure on recent purchases. The pain is not evenly distributed across property types. Apartments have been hit hardest, with nearly half of all resales incurring a loss.

Property TypeLoss-Making Resale Rate
Apartments48%
Townhouses22.5%
Standalone Houses13.4%

Apartment values had fallen about 6% over the past 12 months, against roughly 2% for townhouses, while prices for standalone houses were broadly flat. Properties with smaller plots of land were more vulnerable to loss.

Holding Periods Shape Loss Outcomes

The length of ownership is a critical factor in whether a sale ends in profit or loss. Properties sold at a loss were held for a median period of just 4.5 years. In stark contrast, homes that sold for a profit were held for a median period of 10.4 years. This data indicates that longer holding periods strongly correlate with better financial outcomes in the current market.

Regional Disparities in Loss Rates

Loss rates vary significantly across the country, highlighting localized market weaknesses. Auckland posted the worst regional loss rate in the nation, with more than a quarter of resales under water.

CityLoss-Making Resale Rate
Auckland25.5%
Wellington20.4%
Nelson20%
Christchurch7.5%
Dunedin6.9%
Queenstown5.5%

The financial impact of these trends is substantial. The median loss across homes resold at a loss was NZ$60,000. On the other side, the median gain on profitable resales was NZ$270,000, though this figure is well off its peak of NZ$440,000 in late 2021. In gross terms, sellers still banked NZ$3.6 billion in gains against NZ$179 million in losses for the quarter.

CoreLogic New Zealand's chief property economist, Kelvin Davidson, noted it is not a great time to be a seller. He explained the shifting dynamics, stating, "Apartments tend to deliver less price growth than other property types over time, so are always a little more vulnerable to losses." The current economic climate, marked by an 11-year-high unemployment rate, muted wage gains, and elevated living costs, continues to weigh on the market. For real estate investors, the era of quick flips appears over. The strategy is now clear: buy-and-hold is no longer merely a choice, it is the price of admission.

Related coverage

More from Strategies